Some of you may have read my column yesterday here. I don't think 800 words really do justice to my visit to Perth so here's a longer account.
I was invited to give the keynote speech at a conference on Ten Years after 9/11: Rebuilding Harmony organised by the Centre for Muslim States and Societies (CMSS), University of Western Australia. I jumped at the chance to speak on the role of civil society to rebuild harmony because it gave me a chance to think and write about something a bit different and to meet some people I'd only heard about before especially Prof Samina Yasmeen, the head of CMSS.
Perth weather was glorious, cool but sunny. And the conference was terrific. The auditorium at the University Club was full and the line-up of speakers was interesting. Although it did not start too well. The US Consul-General was given the chance to speak first and to everyone's disappointment she spoke only of the victims of what happened in New York, Philadelphia and Washington DC that day and didn't even mention Iraq and Afghanistan. In the question and answer session that followed, the audience which comprised various Australian academics, journalists, students and anyone who was interested in the subject, asked her some tough questions which she just managed to answer in as calm a manner as possible.
This made me doubly nervous about my speech and I wondered if the audience would be as tough as me. I spoke about how what happened in New York on September 11 was a terrible catastrophe and that we should remember not just those who died in those three American cities but also those in the many wars in other countries since. I spoke about how because of September 11, the civil liberties of Americans, especially Muslim Americans, have been very much curtailed and growing Islamophobia all around the world has made life more difficult for everyone, especially when there are deranged individuals like Anders Breivik in the world.
I also talked about how, sadly, Muslims themselves have often not helped matters, responding in ways that only served to confirm the stereotype in the Western media of the wild-eyed angry Arab man. And how these negative global defensiveness have translated into local defensiveness, including in our beloved country Malaysia where some politicians have used race and religion to polarise people.
But there have been attempts by ordinary people to build bridges and mend ties between different faith communities. I cited Fast for the Nation two years ago and Tali Tenang early last year as two examples of community-level action to unite people and resist attempts by others to drive a wedge between Malaysians. I also talked about how the Arab Spring has done so much to break stereotypes about Muslims by showing that the hunger for freedom and for human rights to be respected is universal, as much wanted by Muslims as anyone else.
To my relief, my audience approved heartily. Over coffee I had several Australians, including some elderly people, come up and say that I had expressed what they thought, that the response to September 11, as terrible as it was, was out of proportion and unjust. Too many people died because of it and too much money was wasted on weapons.
The other speakers were even more enlightening. Dr Azza Anne Aly from Curtin University spoke about other community actions to rebuild harmony. A wellknown radio presenter on religious affairs, John Cleary, spoke about how the media talked about September 11 and how that helped or clouded understanding about the event. A Christian youth leader, Jarrod McKenna, talked about 'loving thy enemy' and how he had worked on a project to getting the people who had raised funds to kill his friend in the Bali bombings to see others as human beings and therefore to stop using violence on them.
After the conference, we went to St George's Cathedral, the main Anglican church in Perth, to attend a choral evensong marking the 10th anniversary of September 11. The church looks modest from the outside but inside has the beautiful stained glass windows that lend a glow to the place and makes it look majestic. The guests that day included the Governor of Western Australia, the Premier, the Lord Mayor of Perth ( who is a woman by the way), the US Consul General and a representative of the WA Leader of the Opposition.
But it was the service itself that was impressive. After some initial hymns, Sheikh Muhammad Agherdieu, the imam of the Masjid al Taqwa in Mirrabooka near Perth got up and recited, in Arabic, the first surah of the Quran, the AlFatihah. For those who may not know what this surah says, here's the English translation which was available in the service programme:
I have to confess that although I knew the imam was going to get up and speak, as soon as he began to recite the AlFatihah, I became overwhelmed by emotions and burst into tears. I think it was because I realised that I would never have this experience at home, where just to be in a place of worship not my own would cause people to suspect my faith. Yet here was an imam confidently getting up to recite the Quran, in its original language, in a church. As far as I could tell, his faith remained intact.
Mine on the other hand expanded and soared. My heart was filled with love for an Islam that is generous and compassionate and respectful of other faiths.
In addition to the AlFatihah, Imam Muhammad recited Surah 3:64:
and Surah 42:15:
http://www.islamicity.com/quranSearch http://www.islamicity.com/quranSearch The service then continued with more hymns, lessons and prayers including one by Rabbi David Freilich, the Perth Hebrew Congregation, Chief Rabbi of Western Australia. This was preceded by the laying of a commemorative wreath by the US Consul General and various other local Americans.
After the service we all had some refreshments in the courtyard outside, in the nice cool weather. I was introduced to the Imam and his wife, a lovely couple who, if you closed your eyes, sounded indistinguishable from any other Australian. While we were chatting, the Chief Rabbi came by to say hello and these two religious officials greeted each other warmly. No, lightning did not strike anyone dead just then.
I have been to many multifaith events and they are always inspiring and gratifying. They make me feel hope that things can change for the better. But later on I went on John Cleary's radio show Sunday Nights where we talked about the conference, about the work of Sisters in Islam, and about being a young Muslim in Australia. (Listen to the podcast here.) As always, there are the detractors. But at least everyone gets an airing.
Anyway it was a good experience and I made some new friends. And for a while I felt united with the world. Perhaps one little good thing did come out of September 11.
And talking of good things, tonight the PM announced the repeal of many of the laws we don't like including the ISA. It's almost unbelievable. But since it is Malaysia Day tomorrow, I'm going to allow myself to bask in positivity for at least the next 24 hours and feel happy.
Happy Malaysia Day, folks!
I was invited to give the keynote speech at a conference on Ten Years after 9/11: Rebuilding Harmony organised by the Centre for Muslim States and Societies (CMSS), University of Western Australia. I jumped at the chance to speak on the role of civil society to rebuild harmony because it gave me a chance to think and write about something a bit different and to meet some people I'd only heard about before especially Prof Samina Yasmeen, the head of CMSS.
Perth weather was glorious, cool but sunny. And the conference was terrific. The auditorium at the University Club was full and the line-up of speakers was interesting. Although it did not start too well. The US Consul-General was given the chance to speak first and to everyone's disappointment she spoke only of the victims of what happened in New York, Philadelphia and Washington DC that day and didn't even mention Iraq and Afghanistan. In the question and answer session that followed, the audience which comprised various Australian academics, journalists, students and anyone who was interested in the subject, asked her some tough questions which she just managed to answer in as calm a manner as possible.
This made me doubly nervous about my speech and I wondered if the audience would be as tough as me. I spoke about how what happened in New York on September 11 was a terrible catastrophe and that we should remember not just those who died in those three American cities but also those in the many wars in other countries since. I spoke about how because of September 11, the civil liberties of Americans, especially Muslim Americans, have been very much curtailed and growing Islamophobia all around the world has made life more difficult for everyone, especially when there are deranged individuals like Anders Breivik in the world.
I also talked about how, sadly, Muslims themselves have often not helped matters, responding in ways that only served to confirm the stereotype in the Western media of the wild-eyed angry Arab man. And how these negative global defensiveness have translated into local defensiveness, including in our beloved country Malaysia where some politicians have used race and religion to polarise people.
But there have been attempts by ordinary people to build bridges and mend ties between different faith communities. I cited Fast for the Nation two years ago and Tali Tenang early last year as two examples of community-level action to unite people and resist attempts by others to drive a wedge between Malaysians. I also talked about how the Arab Spring has done so much to break stereotypes about Muslims by showing that the hunger for freedom and for human rights to be respected is universal, as much wanted by Muslims as anyone else.
To my relief, my audience approved heartily. Over coffee I had several Australians, including some elderly people, come up and say that I had expressed what they thought, that the response to September 11, as terrible as it was, was out of proportion and unjust. Too many people died because of it and too much money was wasted on weapons.
![]() |
| Jarrod McKenna speaking about his work |
The other speakers were even more enlightening. Dr Azza Anne Aly from Curtin University spoke about other community actions to rebuild harmony. A wellknown radio presenter on religious affairs, John Cleary, spoke about how the media talked about September 11 and how that helped or clouded understanding about the event. A Christian youth leader, Jarrod McKenna, talked about 'loving thy enemy' and how he had worked on a project to getting the people who had raised funds to kill his friend in the Bali bombings to see others as human beings and therefore to stop using violence on them.
| Me with some of the lovely students from the Australian Islamic College who had come to attend the conference. |
After the conference, we went to St George's Cathedral, the main Anglican church in Perth, to attend a choral evensong marking the 10th anniversary of September 11. The church looks modest from the outside but inside has the beautiful stained glass windows that lend a glow to the place and makes it look majestic. The guests that day included the Governor of Western Australia, the Premier, the Lord Mayor of Perth ( who is a woman by the way), the US Consul General and a representative of the WA Leader of the Opposition.
| Imam Muhammad (in white cap) waiting to speak |
But it was the service itself that was impressive. After some initial hymns, Sheikh Muhammad Agherdieu, the imam of the Masjid al Taqwa in Mirrabooka near Perth got up and recited, in Arabic, the first surah of the Quran, the AlFatihah. For those who may not know what this surah says, here's the English translation which was available in the service programme:
In the Name of of God, the Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.
Praise be to God, Lord of the Worlds!
The compassionate, the merciful!
King on the day of reckoning!
Thee only do we worship, and to Thee do we cry for help.
Guide Thou us on the straight path,
The path of those to whom Thou hast been gracious, with whom thou
art not angry, and who go not astray.
Mine on the other hand expanded and soared. My heart was filled with love for an Islam that is generous and compassionate and respectful of other faiths.
In addition to the AlFatihah, Imam Muhammad recited Surah 3:64:
Say:O People of the book! Let us come together upon a formula which is common between us -that we shall not serve anyone but God, that we shall associate none with Him.
and Surah 42:15:
Because of this*, then, summon us all to pursue the right course, as thou has been bidden (by God); and do not follow their likes and dislikes, but say: "I believe in whatever revelation God has bestowed from on high; and I am bidden to bring about equity in your mutual views**. Good is our Sustainer as well as your Sustainer. To us shall be accounted our deed, and to you, your deeds. Let there be no contention between us and you. God will bring us all together for with Him is all journeys' end."
(* I.e., because of this breach of the original unity of men’s faith in the One God.(Quran Ref: 42:15 ))
(** Lit., "between you" - i.e., "to induce you to be more tolerant of one another": evidently an allusion to the bitterness which stands in the way of an understanding between the various sects and schools of thought in all revealed religions.(Quran Ref: 42:15 ))
| Imam Muhammad greeting Rabbi Freilich and his wife |
After the service we all had some refreshments in the courtyard outside, in the nice cool weather. I was introduced to the Imam and his wife, a lovely couple who, if you closed your eyes, sounded indistinguishable from any other Australian. While we were chatting, the Chief Rabbi came by to say hello and these two religious officials greeted each other warmly. No, lightning did not strike anyone dead just then.
I have been to many multifaith events and they are always inspiring and gratifying. They make me feel hope that things can change for the better. But later on I went on John Cleary's radio show Sunday Nights where we talked about the conference, about the work of Sisters in Islam, and about being a young Muslim in Australia. (Listen to the podcast here.) As always, there are the detractors. But at least everyone gets an airing.
Anyway it was a good experience and I made some new friends. And for a while I felt united with the world. Perhaps one little good thing did come out of September 11.
And talking of good things, tonight the PM announced the repeal of many of the laws we don't like including the ISA. It's almost unbelievable. But since it is Malaysia Day tomorrow, I'm going to allow myself to bask in positivity for at least the next 24 hours and feel happy.
Happy Malaysia Day, folks!


Dear Datin Paduka, SELAMAT HARI MALAYSIA ANAK-ANAK MALAYSIA!!!
ReplyDeleteDear Marina,
ReplyDeleteare you going to The Future of Islamic Feminism on sunday?
Rendrazaleigh, yes, will be there, insyaAllah.
ReplyDeleteWow, this was such a pleasant read. I was not bored for even one second! My eyes were just glued to the screen.
ReplyDeleteThis is wonderful and I hope, InsyaAllah one day Malaysia will be able to hold such multi-faith conferences. We just must!
I think a lot of the so-called 'Islamic leaders' in Malaysia are not fully at peace with themselves to be at peace with others. THere's a deep-rooted insecurity in them and I've no idea what their problem is. Perhaps it's the false information they're fed with?
Over-thinking? SO many reasons.
We should drag them to these multi-faith conferences overseas out there and let their hearts and EYES open up. Dear God, please let that happen.
I'm sharing the same concern.
ReplyDeleteMuslim speaks freely at church here in the US in any inter-religion program.
In Malaysia, a muslim can't even go 5 meters close to a church.
How is it then, are we going to be able to introduce this religion of peace to other people who are waiting for the call?
HARMONY THROUGH FAITH - 170911
ReplyDeleteLet people of faith in all good faith
Come together to promote harmony
And hear melodies without monotony
Building strong bonds that won't easily fade.
(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng
http://motivationinmotion.blogspot.com
Sat.17th Sept.2011.
Hello Marina,
ReplyDeleteIts always a great pleasure to read your post as your pengalaman also gave dwell into the readers wholefully as if they were apart of your trip and experience as well.
In this little piece of story, it gave us much hope that Malaysians too can be united as a whole. They can be united as Malaysians and not as any political parties or individuals.
We are what we are today is because of our leaders' short sighted greedy ambitions that uses the rakyat as their tools to gain personal wealth.
Overzealous religious leaders too have been immersed in political gamut so far so that the definition of good faiths have been distorted to suit the current needs.
Like many here, I too wished that someday there will be a leader who would be strong headed to reform, and who is unbiased towards any religion or race of Malaysia.
Till then, we can only hope and pray that they will no longer be any religion tensions among the people of Malaysia.
thank you Marina...
Future though....
ReplyDelete(Zephaniah 3:9) For then I shall give to peoples the change to a pure language, in order for them all to call upon the name of Jehovah, in order to serve him shoulder to shoulder.’
RS,
ReplyDeleteIslamic leaders here think that joining anything interfaith would be stooping to low and insulting the Supremacy Of Islam. Any remember that the religion is being threatened by everything & everyone including Blueberry Chesse Cake!
Hello MM,
ReplyDeleteThank you for a lovely post. I enjoyed reading it.
Datin Paduka,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing this. I wonder when will such harmonious interfaith relationship prevail in Malaysia.
Joshua Lopez says
ReplyDelete"Islamic leaders here think that joining anything interfaith would be stooping to low and insulting the Supremacy Of Islam."
I have to agree with this statement on the surface.
At a deeper level however, and to those Islamic leaders who are better guided, the teaching of Islam is not about supremacy at all. It is about achieving inner peace and spreading this inner peace in spirit and in material.
In short, a muslim would queue for food, under whatever circumstances. Thus the Japanese who suffered recent tsunami can be said to be of a much hugher quality muslim than most others, and the world nod in respect of these Japanese who queue up for food under such extreme conditions.
The world is suffering because of the gross misintrepetation of Islam. The name of the religion itself has now become a bad word. Citing people like Joseph as Islamophobic does not help, what will help is a demostration of what true Islam can offer the world. Otherwise, religion will be discarded as mere ancient belief systems no longer relevant in our lives.
I watched a documentary on Discovery Channel showing a four year old preacher which the community happily accepts as having "Jesus" in him, the documentary entitled "Pint-Sized Preachers".
I think we ought to ask ourselves, what will become of our civilisation if we begin to listen to a four year old preacher, and forego wisdom of the elders, the experienced and the experts ( people of the books ).
So in a way Josua is right, but i ask Joseph that you look not at labels, but for the real substance.
Nowadays, when we buy chocolate, unless it tastes good and fresh, it isn't chocolate as it should be.
And so people like Joseph are continuously misled, but it's not entirely his fault is it ?
What say you ?